In legal and commercial circles, mediation is often viewed through a single lens: Did the parties settle?
Settlement rates are frequently used to measure the effectiveness of mediation, and while reaching an agreement is undoubtedly an important outcome, it is not the only indicator of success. In fact, focusing exclusively on settlement can cause attorneys, mediators, and clients to overlook some of the most valuable contributions mediation makes to dispute resolution.
The true value of mediation lies not merely in the destination, but in the journey. It creates opportunities for understanding, communication, relationship preservation, and informed decision-making that can significantly influence the future course of a dispute. Some of mediation’s most meaningful achievements cannot be measured by a signed settlement agreement on the day of the mediation.
As mediators and legal practitioners, perhaps it is time to broaden how we define success.
Mediation creates space for productive communication
One of mediation’s greatest strengths is its ability to restore communication where communication has broken down.
Most disputes reach mediation only after parties have become entrenched in their positions. Conversations have often been replaced by formal correspondence, legal threats, assumptions, misunderstandings, and emotional reactions. In some cases, parties have not engaged in meaningful dialogue for months or even years.
Mediation provides a structured environment in which parties can communicate safely and constructively. It allows individuals to speak, be heard, and begin engaging with issues that may have become obscured by conflict.
For attorneys, this often provides valuable insight into the motivations and concerns driving the dispute. For the parties themselves, it presents an opportunity to move beyond adversarial exchanges and towards genuine dialogue.
Even when settlement is not immediately achieved, improved communication frequently reduces hostility, lowers tension, and creates a foundation for future negotiations. It is difficult to resolve disputes where communication has completely collapsed. Mediation helps rebuild that essential bridge.
Mediation clarifies misunderstandings
Many disputes grow not because of genuine disagreement, but because of misunderstandings that accumulate over time.
Parties often enter mediation carrying assumptions about the other side’s intentions, expectations, motivations, or willingness to compromise. These assumptions are frequently inaccurate but become accepted as fact through prolonged conflict.
A carefully facilitated mediation process allows parties to test these assumptions against reality.
A business partner may discover that the dispute is not about dishonesty but about differing expectations. A family member may realise that a perceived slight was never intentional. A litigant may discover that the other party’s priorities are very different from what was previously believed.
This clarification alone can create significant value.
When misunderstandings are addressed, the dispute often becomes less personal and more manageable. The parties become better equipped to evaluate the issues objectively and identify practical ways forward.
In many matters, removing misconceptions is one of the most important steps toward eventual resolution.
Mediation helps parties understand interests rather than positions
Legal disputes are frequently argued through positions. Positions, however, rarely tell the full story.
Behind every position lies an underlying interest, concern, fear, need, or objective. These deeper interests are often what truly drive behaviour and decision-making.
Mediation is uniquely positioned to uncover these interests. Rather than asking only what a party wants, mediation explores why they want it.
Understanding these underlying interests allows parties to move beyond rigid demands and consider solutions that may not have been apparent at the outset. It encourages creativity, flexibility, and collaborative problem-solving.
Even where no immediate agreement is reached, a deeper understanding of each party’s interests often lays the foundation for future settlement discussions and more productive negotiations.
Mediation narrows the issues in dispute
Success in mediation is not always measured by complete resolution.
Sometimes the most meaningful progress occurs when the parties reduce the number of issues that remain contested.
Complex disputes often contain multiple layers of disagreement. Through the mediation process, parties may discover areas of consensus, clarify points of contention, or settle certain aspects of the matter whilst leaving others for further consideration.
This narrowing of issues delivers substantial value.
For attorneys, it can reduce litigation costs, shorten proceedings, streamline preparation, and improve case management. For clients, it can lessen uncertainty and provide clarity regarding the true issues requiring attention.
A dispute that remains only partially resolved is often far more manageable than the dispute that entered the mediation room.
Progress should not be underestimated simply because every issue was not resolved.
Talk to us
Wondering what mediation could achieve in your matter?
Mediation preserves relationships
Unlike litigation, mediation recognises that many disputes occur between people who must continue interacting long after the legal conflict has ended.
Parents remain co-parents. Business partners may continue collaborating. Family members remain connected. Neighbours continue living side by side. Employers and employees may need to maintain professional relationships.
Traditional adversarial processes can place enormous strain on these relationships, often making future interaction more difficult. Mediation offers an alternative.
By encouraging respectful dialogue and mutual understanding, mediation helps preserve dignity and reduce the damage that conflict can cause. Even when parties remain divided on important issues, they often leave mediation with a greater appreciation of each other’s perspectives.
For many clients, preserving an important relationship is every bit as valuable as achieving a financial or legal outcome. This may be one of mediation’s most significant contributions.
Mediation supports better decision-making
Disputes are often accompanied by stress, frustration, uncertainty, and fear. These emotions can cloud judgment and make informed decision-making difficult. Mediation creates an environment where parties can evaluate their options more carefully and realistically.
Through discussion, questioning, reflection, and reality testing, parties gain a clearer understanding of the risks, opportunities, and consequences associated with various outcomes.
They become better informed about their choices, develop a greater appreciation of the practical realities surrounding the dispute and are encouraged to make decisions based on understanding rather than reaction.
Even where settlement is not achieved immediately, parties frequently leave mediation with a more realistic assessment of their situation and a clearer understanding of their options moving forward.
That clarity often has lasting value.
Mediation lays the groundwork for future resolution
One of the most overlooked benefits of mediation is its capacity to prepare parties for eventual settlement.
Not every dispute is ready to settle on a particular day. The parties may require additional information, expert advice, organisational approvals, financial certainty, or simply time to reflect on what has been discussed.
This does not mean the mediation lacked value. In fact, many settlements occur after mediation has formally concluded.
The conversations that take place during mediation often continue to influence decision-making long after the parties leave the room. Positions soften. Perspectives evolve. Risks become clearer. New opportunities emerge.
What appeared impossible during mediation may become achievable weeks later precisely because the mediation process helped the parties move closer to understanding one another.
Experienced mediators frequently observe that mediation plants seeds that continue growing long after the session ends.
In practice: what to ask when a mediation ends without full settlement
Karen Malan has mediated more than 400 matters. Her view is that the most useful question at the end of a mediation is a different one from the question most people ask:
“The next time a mediation concludes, perhaps the most important question is not: ‘Did the parties settle?’, but rather ‘What value did the mediation create?’”
Karen Malan
For attorneys and their clients, that question can be broken down into practical parts. After a mediation that did not resolve everything, it is worth asking:
- Which issues are no longer in dispute, and can they be recorded?
- What did we learn about the other side’s real interests and priorities?
- Which assumptions about the other side turned out to be wrong?
- Has our assessment of the risks, costs and likely outcomes changed?
- What information, expert input or approvals are still needed before a decision can be made?
- Is the relationship in a better or worse position than before the mediation?
- What would make a further mediation session, or direct negotiation, worthwhile?
In court-annexed mediation under Rule 41A, these answers also help the legal team prepare for what comes next, whether that is a resumed mediation, a narrower trial or a settlement reached weeks later. As Karen puts it, “A dispute that remains only partially resolved is often far more manageable than the dispute that entered the mediation room.”
Redefining success in mediation
Perhaps the mediation profession has become too focused on counting agreements and not focused enough on measuring value.
Settlement remains an important outcome and should never be discounted. However, mediation delivers far more than settlement alone.
It improves communication, clarifies misunderstandings, uncovers interests, narrows disputes, preserves relationships, supports informed decision-making and creates pathways for future resolution.
Each of these outcomes contributes meaningfully to the dispute resolution process and to the broader goal of helping people navigate conflict constructively.
The next time a mediation concludes, perhaps the most important question is not: “Did the parties settle?”, but rather “What value did the mediation create?”
When viewed through that lens, the hidden successes of mediation become impossible to ignore.
Frequently asked questions
Is a mediation that does not settle a failure?
Not necessarily. A mediation may improve communication, clarify misunderstandings, narrow the issues and help parties make better-informed decisions, even if no agreement is signed on the day.
Can parties settle after the mediation has ended?
Yes. Many settlements are reached after the formal mediation has concluded, once the parties have had time to reflect, obtain advice or secure approvals.
What does “narrowing the issues” mean?
It means reducing the number of points the parties still disagree on. Settling some issues and leaving others for later can reduce cost, shorten proceedings and bring clarity.
Who benefits from mediation even without settlement?
Parties who must continue to deal with each other, such as co-parents, family members and business partners, often benefit most, because mediation can preserve dignity and reduce the damage that conflict causes.
Measuring what matters
MV Inc. mediates family, civil and commercial disputes, including court-annexed matters under Rule 41A. To discuss whether mediation suits your matter, request a confidential consultation or read more about our family mediation and civil and commercial mediation services.
About the author
Karen Malan
An attorney of nearly two decades’ standing turned full-time mediator, with more than 400 matters mediated across family and divorce, civil and commercial, and personal injury and Road Accident Fund disputes.
This article is general information about mediation practice in South Africa and is not legal advice. Mediation does not guarantee settlement or any particular outcome, and you should obtain advice on your own matter before acting.
MV Inc (Malan Vermeulen Incorporated) · Ground Floor, Quadrum 3, 50 Constantia Boulevard, Floracliffe, Johannesburg, 1709 · 010 980 5160 · [email protected]